Why Sohn’s top stock pickers want investors to play it safe

Top global money managers are telling investors to steer clear of companies that don’t make money and invest instead in unloved but profitable businesses.

Why Sohn’s top stock pickers want investors to play it safe

November 18, 2022
Top global money managers are telling investors to steer clear of companies that don’t make money and invest instead in unloved but profitable businesses.
Read Transcript

Top global money managers are telling investors to steer clear of companies that don’t make money and invest instead in unloved but profitable businesses, as continuing central bank interest rate rises threaten to keep markets falling.

They railed against being tempted back into the sort of high-growth, loss-making stocks that have been popular for years but are now dangerous because they rely on the capital markets to survive.

In an event dominated by geopolitical discussion about Russia and Ukraine, former hedge fund manager turned human rights activist Bill Browder told the audience at the Sohn Hearts & Minds investment conference in Hobart on Friday to sit on the sidelines – and in cash – for a bit longer.

MONA founder David Walsh says equities markets need growth to offset risk. Alastair Bett

Historic Sohn picks such as Delivery Hero, Megaport and crypto exchange Coinbase were this year replaced by fallen financial services giant AMP, toll road operator Transurban, and Champion Iron.

“There are going to be some really sweet opportunities to invest once we get to a point when interest rates are peaking and inflation is starting to go down,” Mr Browder said, forecasting opportunities across “all sorts of assets”.

Professional gambler and Museum of Old and New Art founder David Walsh issued a brutal warning to the 600-strong audience in Hobart that risk levels are rising and could ultimately sink returns in equities markets.

“What is not clear to me is whether the variance, the amount of risk, isn’t also going up. If it is, and if that variance is expanding faster than the growth of the market, then one day it will all turn to shit.”

Catherine Allfrey backed the inflation protection of Transurban. Alastair Bett

At the annual conference, which raises funds for medical research, speakers are invited to pitch one stock to invest in over the next 12 months. The best ideas create the bulk of the portfolio for the $560 million ASX-listed Hearts & Minds investment fund.

The fund, which donates a percentage of assets to charity, has slid 41 per cent over one year to trade at an 18 per cent discount to its net asset value after its run of tech-heavy bets soured.

“As investors we always need to consider risk and commodities are cyclical, but that also means miners bounce back,” Regal Partners’ Tim Elliott said in his presentation on ASX-listed Canadian iron ore miner Champion. “Real risk is buying some profitless growth stock on 20 times projected sales on heroic assumptions which often disappoint.”

Champion, Mr Elliott said, allowed investors to buy “hard assets at less than half their replacement cost” in a market that was difficult and expensive for new competitors to enter.

Fred Woollard of Australian fund manager Samuel Terry eyed deep value in AMP because “the sum of the parts are worth more than its market capitalisation of $4 billion”.

Tribeca’s Jun Bei Liu decked herself out in luxury brands to make the bull case for China Tourism Group Duty Free. Alastair Bett

Mr Woollard said conservative value investors had been wrong about AMP for years, but “AMP keeps getting cheaper”, and with a new CEO at the helm the time to buy was now.

‘Don’t leave this one on the road’

Among the other stock tips touted by fund managers were Eurofins Scientific by David Cooper, and Claremont’s Bob Desmond – in sneakers and a Nike jumper – picked sportswear giant Nike. Tribeca’s Jun Bei Liu decked herself out in luxury brands to make the bull case for retailer China Tourism Group Duty Free.

Tim Carleton of Australian hedge fund Auscap told investors to buy Carsales.com, which he said was trading like a tech stock when it in fact had more in common with a media company.

“With investing you don’t get extra returns for increasing the degree of difficulty. My advice: don’t leave this one on the road,” he said.

Wavestone’s Catherine Allfrey tipped monopoly toll road operator Transburban: “Inflation with this stock doesn’t matter because the prices it charges are linked to CPI,” she said.

While Transurban has high debt levels, inflation will serve to increase nominal revenues whilst devaluing the debt in real terms.

The shift in favoured stocks reflects a turbulent year in which higher inflation forced central banks to raise interest rates sharply, while the war in Ukraine strained the global supply of commodities.

Several presenters revealed they were hunting for value created by the sharp sell-off in technology stocks.

FACT Capital’s Joyce Meng tipped Irish video game developer Keywords Studios and Nick Griffin of Munro Partners said the 30 per cent slide in Dutch semiconductor play ASML allowed investors to buy into a trillion-dollar opportunity.

Existential threat

Sohn Hearts & Minds was first held in 2016 and has raised $40 million for medical research.

But so-called fundamental investors – those guided by the founding principles of investing, such as attractive free cashflow and sustainable competitive advantage – are facing an existential threat.

New York-based hedge fund manager Ricky Sandler of Eminence Capital said fundamental investors accounted for 75 per cent of the equity market 15 years ago, but that had shrunk to 45 per cent.

Meanwhile, the rise of environmental, social and governance investing, increased retail trading and hyperactive hedge fund trading strategies, had further marginalised the role of stock pickers in setting prices. This, he said, meant investors required a “mindset change”.

“Fundamental investors are mostly irrelevant to the stock market in the short run,” he said. “Over time, we think, the markets are a weighing machine and fundamental investors eventually, if they can stick with their convictions, will win out.”

Stocks were not more volatile and their movements “no longer provide fundamental investors with clues”, he said.

Tasmanian Premier Jeremy Rockliff opened the conference, and AFL chief executive Gillon McLachlan made the case for a Tasmanian stadium. The event closed with Australian rock band Hunters & Collectors.

This article was originally posted by The Australian Financial Review here.

Licensed by Copyright Agency. You must not copy this work without permission.

Top global money managers are telling investors to steer clear of companies that don’t make money and invest instead in unloved but profitable businesses, as continuing central bank interest rate rises threaten to keep markets falling.

They railed against being tempted back into the sort of high-growth, loss-making stocks that have been popular for years but are now dangerous because they rely on the capital markets to survive.

In an event dominated by geopolitical discussion about Russia and Ukraine, former hedge fund manager turned human rights activist Bill Browder told the audience at the Sohn Hearts & Minds investment conference in Hobart on Friday to sit on the sidelines – and in cash – for a bit longer.

MONA founder David Walsh says equities markets need growth to offset risk. Alastair Bett

Historic Sohn picks such as Delivery Hero, Megaport and crypto exchange Coinbase were this year replaced by fallen financial services giant AMP, toll road operator Transurban, and Champion Iron.

“There are going to be some really sweet opportunities to invest once we get to a point when interest rates are peaking and inflation is starting to go down,” Mr Browder said, forecasting opportunities across “all sorts of assets”.

Professional gambler and Museum of Old and New Art founder David Walsh issued a brutal warning to the 600-strong audience in Hobart that risk levels are rising and could ultimately sink returns in equities markets.

“What is not clear to me is whether the variance, the amount of risk, isn’t also going up. If it is, and if that variance is expanding faster than the growth of the market, then one day it will all turn to shit.”

Catherine Allfrey backed the inflation protection of Transurban. Alastair Bett

At the annual conference, which raises funds for medical research, speakers are invited to pitch one stock to invest in over the next 12 months. The best ideas create the bulk of the portfolio for the $560 million ASX-listed Hearts & Minds investment fund.

The fund, which donates a percentage of assets to charity, has slid 41 per cent over one year to trade at an 18 per cent discount to its net asset value after its run of tech-heavy bets soured.

“As investors we always need to consider risk and commodities are cyclical, but that also means miners bounce back,” Regal Partners’ Tim Elliott said in his presentation on ASX-listed Canadian iron ore miner Champion. “Real risk is buying some profitless growth stock on 20 times projected sales on heroic assumptions which often disappoint.”

Champion, Mr Elliott said, allowed investors to buy “hard assets at less than half their replacement cost” in a market that was difficult and expensive for new competitors to enter.

Fred Woollard of Australian fund manager Samuel Terry eyed deep value in AMP because “the sum of the parts are worth more than its market capitalisation of $4 billion”.

Tribeca’s Jun Bei Liu decked herself out in luxury brands to make the bull case for China Tourism Group Duty Free. Alastair Bett

Mr Woollard said conservative value investors had been wrong about AMP for years, but “AMP keeps getting cheaper”, and with a new CEO at the helm the time to buy was now.

‘Don’t leave this one on the road’

Among the other stock tips touted by fund managers were Eurofins Scientific by David Cooper, and Claremont’s Bob Desmond – in sneakers and a Nike jumper – picked sportswear giant Nike. Tribeca’s Jun Bei Liu decked herself out in luxury brands to make the bull case for retailer China Tourism Group Duty Free.

Tim Carleton of Australian hedge fund Auscap told investors to buy Carsales.com, which he said was trading like a tech stock when it in fact had more in common with a media company.

“With investing you don’t get extra returns for increasing the degree of difficulty. My advice: don’t leave this one on the road,” he said.

Wavestone’s Catherine Allfrey tipped monopoly toll road operator Transburban: “Inflation with this stock doesn’t matter because the prices it charges are linked to CPI,” she said.

While Transurban has high debt levels, inflation will serve to increase nominal revenues whilst devaluing the debt in real terms.

The shift in favoured stocks reflects a turbulent year in which higher inflation forced central banks to raise interest rates sharply, while the war in Ukraine strained the global supply of commodities.

Several presenters revealed they were hunting for value created by the sharp sell-off in technology stocks.

FACT Capital’s Joyce Meng tipped Irish video game developer Keywords Studios and Nick Griffin of Munro Partners said the 30 per cent slide in Dutch semiconductor play ASML allowed investors to buy into a trillion-dollar opportunity.

Existential threat

Sohn Hearts & Minds was first held in 2016 and has raised $40 million for medical research.

But so-called fundamental investors – those guided by the founding principles of investing, such as attractive free cashflow and sustainable competitive advantage – are facing an existential threat.

New York-based hedge fund manager Ricky Sandler of Eminence Capital said fundamental investors accounted for 75 per cent of the equity market 15 years ago, but that had shrunk to 45 per cent.

Meanwhile, the rise of environmental, social and governance investing, increased retail trading and hyperactive hedge fund trading strategies, had further marginalised the role of stock pickers in setting prices. This, he said, meant investors required a “mindset change”.

“Fundamental investors are mostly irrelevant to the stock market in the short run,” he said. “Over time, we think, the markets are a weighing machine and fundamental investors eventually, if they can stick with their convictions, will win out.”

Stocks were not more volatile and their movements “no longer provide fundamental investors with clues”, he said.

Tasmanian Premier Jeremy Rockliff opened the conference, and AFL chief executive Gillon McLachlan made the case for a Tasmanian stadium. The event closed with Australian rock band Hunters & Collectors.

This article was originally posted by The Australian Financial Review here.

Licensed by Copyright Agency. You must not copy this work without permission.

Disclaimer: This material has been prepared by Australian Financial Review, published on Nov 18, 2022. HM1 is not responsible for the content of linked websites or content prepared by third party. The inclusion of these links and third-party content does not in any way imply any form of endorsement by HM1 of the products or services provided by persons or organisations who are responsible for the linked websites and third-party content. This information is for general information only and does not consider the objectives, financial situation or needs of any person. Before making an investment decision, you should read the relevant disclosure document (if appropriate) and seek professional advice to determine whether the investment and information is suitable for you.

facebook
linkedin
All
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
March 14, 2025

$1.4 million boost for SA medical research

South Australian medical research will receive a $1.4 million cash injection, as a direct result of a major investment and philanthropy conference held in Adelaide.

Read More
Anthony Scaramucci’s time in the White House was brief but memorable. APAnthony Scaramucci’s time in the White House was brief but memorable. APAnthony Scaramucci’s time in the White House was brief but memorable. APAnthony Scaramucci’s time in the White House was brief but memorable. AP
May 19, 2025

Why ‘The Mooch’ thinks Trump is more dangerous this time around

Anthony Scaramucci says Trump has fewer constraints on his worst instincts in his second administration. But he still gets bored easily.

Read More
Image caption: Anthony “The Mooch” Scaramucci at the New York headquarters of his SkyBridge Capital last week. Picture: Jaclyn LichtImage caption: Anthony “The Mooch” Scaramucci at the New York headquarters of his SkyBridge Capital last week. Picture: Jaclyn LichtImage caption: Anthony “The Mooch” Scaramucci at the New York headquarters of his SkyBridge Capital last week. Picture: Jaclyn LichtImage caption: Anthony “The Mooch” Scaramucci at the New York headquarters of his SkyBridge Capital last week. Picture: Jaclyn Licht
May 19, 2025

My biggest mistake: Anthony Scaramucci on what makes Donald Trump tick

On Elon Musk, money and the White House, fast-talking Wall Street hedge fund manager and former Trump communications director Anthony Scaramucci tells it as he sees it.

Read More
A bull case for Bitcoin even as it trades near record levels. Picture: AFPA bull case for Bitcoin even as it trades near record levels. Picture: AFPA bull case for Bitcoin even as it trades near record levels. Picture: AFPA bull case for Bitcoin even as it trades near record levels. Picture: AFP
May 19, 2025

Bitcoin ‘on track’ for $US200,000: Anthony Scaramucci

Bitcoin could hit as much as $US200,000 ($311,000) by the end of this year, fuelled by surging inflows into exchange-traded funds and Donald Trump’s erratic policymaking.

Read More
Anthony Scaramucci says America has no choice but to lower tariffs on China further. Jaclyn LichtAnthony Scaramucci says America has no choice but to lower tariffs on China further. Jaclyn LichtAnthony Scaramucci says America has no choice but to lower tariffs on China further. Jaclyn LichtAnthony Scaramucci says America has no choice but to lower tariffs on China further. Jaclyn Licht
May 19, 2025

‘The Mooch’ says Trump will have to cut China tariffs below 10pc

Scaramucci, who is best known as The Mooch, is the first big-name global investor to be confirmed for the Sohn Hearts & Minds conference in Sydney in November.

Read More
Matthew McLennan in his office at First Eagle Investments in New York. Picture: Jaclyn LichtMatthew McLennan in his office at First Eagle Investments in New York. Picture: Jaclyn LichtMatthew McLennan in his office at First Eagle Investments in New York. Picture: Jaclyn LichtMatthew McLennan in his office at First Eagle Investments in New York. Picture: Jaclyn Licht
July 7, 2025

A golden year for Wall Street’s Australian stock picker

Matthew McLennan’s $14.5 billion position in gold bars and miners paid off handsomely for First Eagle this year. But he insists the precious metal still has room to run.

Read More
Stillpoint Investments founder and chief investment officer Eric Wong. Picture: Jaclyn LichtStillpoint Investments founder and chief investment officer Eric Wong. Picture: Jaclyn LichtStillpoint Investments founder and chief investment officer Eric Wong. Picture: Jaclyn LichtStillpoint Investments founder and chief investment officer Eric Wong. Picture: Jaclyn Licht
September 25, 2025

Stillpoint founder Eric Wong reveals major China tech investment strategy

Eric Wong will present his investment case at the Sohn Hearts & Minds conference at the Sydney Opera House on Friday, November 14.

Read More
October 1, 2025

Billionaire hedge fund manager enacts ‘little short’ on the market

Investing veteran Lord Michael Hintze says he’s taking out insurance against expensive debt and equity markets that are being propelled by passive flows.

Read More
October 1, 2025

Hedge fund guru Michael Hintze can't out-trade machines but he can still 'out-invest' them

Billionaire hedge fund manager Michael Hintze says the world is more dangerous than he has ever seen, artificial intelligence is stifling people’s ability to learn and process information.

Read More
Marathon Resource Advisors founder and chief investment officer Robert Mullin in San Francisco.Marathon Resource Advisors founder and chief investment officer Robert Mullin in San Francisco.Marathon Resource Advisors founder and chief investment officer Robert Mullin in San Francisco.Marathon Resource Advisors founder and chief investment officer Robert Mullin in San Francisco.
October 5, 2025

Marathon CIO Robert Mullin reveals why gold stocks are still undervalued

The son of a stockbroker, Mr Mullin has more than 30 years' investing experience and is chief investment officer at Marathon Resource Advisors in San Francisco, a company he founded.

Read More
First Eagle Investments co-head of global value Matthew McLennan. Picture: Jaclyn LichtFirst Eagle Investments co-head of global value Matthew McLennan. Picture: Jaclyn LichtFirst Eagle Investments co-head of global value Matthew McLennan. Picture: Jaclyn LichtFirst Eagle Investments co-head of global value Matthew McLennan. Picture: Jaclyn Licht
October 6, 2025

First Eagle’s Matthew McLennan on the monetary force that could be ‘rocket fuel’ for the Australian dollar

Matthew McLennan, the co-head of the global value team and portfolio manager at the $US161bn ($243bn) First Eagle Investments, stormed the market with a bullish bet on gold.

Read More
October 10, 2025

Anthony Scaramucci’s advice to our PM is to seek his Canadian counterpart’s counsel

Beyond Wall Street, The Mooch is better known for his cutting takes on US politics in the popular podcast The Rest is Politics: US, which he hosts with BBC’s long-term North American correspondent Katty Kay.

Read More
October 19, 2025

Munro Partners' Qiao Ma reveals AI investment strategy

Qiao Ma has a simple test for spotting the investment opportunities that will define the next decade. Take the technology apart and see what’s inside.

Read More
October 21, 2025

Meet the 2025 Conference Managers

Following a global search, the Conference Fund Manager Selection Committee is pleased to share ten new managers for 2025.

Read More
October 31, 2025

The 42pc gain that shows why Sohn is a stock picker’s delight

It turns out you could have outperformed the seemingly unstoppable magnificent seven tech stocks if you simply acted on the 11 stock picks at Sohn last year.

Read More